Nullify Caster results?
Fri, 16 Oct 2009 12:00
The ANC wants the International Association of Athletics
Federation (IAAF) to declare null and void the results of athlete
Caster Semenya's gender verification tests.
The tests, done in South Africa and Berlin, were not conducted
in keeping with IAAF's gender verification policies and rules,
spokesman Jackson Mthembu told a media briefing in Johannesburg.
An ANC task team, established earlier this month to support the
gold medallist, met with various people involved in the saga.
"We then decided to request a meeting with the IAAF, in which we plan to advise them to declare the test results null and void ,"
said Mthembu.
He said the IAAF's policy required that an athlete or team
should raise a challenge or complaint for the tests to be
conducted.
"Our investigation revealed that this did not happen. Also, with
the test done here (South Africa), the composition of the panel
that can examine an athlete was not according to the IAAF
regulations," said Mthembu.
The IAAF requires that a medical evaluation should be conducted
by a panel comprising gyneacologist, endocrinologist, psychologist,
internal medical specialist as well as an expert on gender and
transgender issues.
"This should also be happening in the strictest confidence, but
obviously, this has not happened with the Berlin tests. It is only
when the athlete agrees that it can be made public. Semenya's
rights have been infringed," said Mthembu, adding that had Semenya
been from a developed country, her testing would not have been
handled this way.
The whole issue smacked of politicking, he said.
"I don't think this was just a mistake by the IAAF. The country
is being undermined. Had we been a developed country, we would not
be here today," said Mthembu.
The task team recently met with Athletics South Africa (ASA),
and the meeting "did not change our stance on the manner the body
handled the issue".
ANC general-secretary Gwede Mantashe told a press briefing last
month that the way ASA managed the gender controversy surrounding
Semenya was "disgusting".
"We need to be upright in censuring the officials who handled
the matter.
The ANC's NEC looked into the issue and felt it was disgusting
the way it was managed... ASA didn't handle the matter with the
utmost transparency and honesty," said Mantashe.
Mthembu said on Friday that the party wished ASA had done better
but could not sanction them. The SA Sport Confederation and Olympic
Committee was dealing with the matter, Mthembu said.
However, he said the IAAF must apologise for its poor handling
of the issue.
He said: "We will advice them to publicly and unconditionally
apologise to Caster, her family and the enter country for violating
her rights.
"Gender testing has been done several times before but results
were never leaked to the media. We are not even aware of some of
the tests they did but with Caster, the so-called results were
published by the international and local media because of leaks. We
are aggrieved."
ANC NEC member Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, who is also part of
the task team, urged everyone to remember that Semenya was a human
being, who is emotionally disturbed. "We should all respect and
protect this child who has gone through this terrible ordeal," said
Madikizela-Mandela.
The team announced that it was preparing to launch a celebratory
programme for athletes Semenya, Mbulaeni Mulaudzi, the men's 800m
gold medallist, and silver medallist in men's long jump, Kgotso
Mokoena.
"We never got to celebrate their victory because of the poor
handling of Caster's gender testing," Mthembu said.
The IAAF ordered gender tests on 18-year-old Semenya after she
won the 800m World Athletics Championships in Berlin, Germany in
August.
The body had refused to comment on reports that the tests showed
she was a hermaphrodite.