A case involving an SAPS captain who says she was twice
overlooked for a position because she is white continues in the
Labour Court in Johannesburg on Wednesday.
Retired police commissioner Abraham Johannes Burger was expected
to continue giving evidence on Wednesday morning on circumstances
around decisions taken not to appoint Captain Renate Barnard to a
Superintendent position.
He told the court on Tuesday that Barnard's appointment would
have improved service delivery within a unit dealing with public
grievances.
The unit, called the national inspectorate division, deals with
complaints from members of the public who feel investigating
officers were not investigating their matters properly or not
giving them attention at all.
Said Burger on Tuesday: "I recommended that she be appointed...
that there was a vast difference between her and the next candidate
and also because of her competence."
He said Barnard's appointment to a senior position would have
also boosted morale within the police's national inspectorate
division.
Those below her would have served the public diligently in the
hope of being promoted themselves, he said.
"Those below her would have worked harder, seeing that there was
room for improvement within the department," said Burger.
He had twice recommended Barnard for the position, first in 2005
and again in 2006 but when the recommendations were sent through to
National Police Commissioner Jackie Selebi's office, he had decided
not to appoint her because the position was meant to address gender
equity in Barnard's department.
"He [Selebi] wanted to ensure that all units adhered to the
Employment Equity Act, in line with equity plans of the [South
African Police Service]," said Senior Superintendent Johannes
Phetholo Ramothoka.
He is based at the SAPS' career management unit in Pretoria.
"The appointment of the candidate was not going to be in line
with guidelines provided by the equity guidelines.
"White females were over-represented by five at salary level
nine so her appointment would have meant an over-representativity
on that level," he said, adding that appointments had to reflect
the country's population.
Defence counsel Johan Grogan was expected to call another
witness once Burger was done giving evidence.