Minister for Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs Sicelo Shiceka.Sapa
Shiceka 'plays race card'
Tue, 09 Mar 2010 12:00
Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs Minister Sicelo
Shiceka's "declaration of war" against white South Africans shows
his lack of understanding of the problems in the country's
municipalities, the National Taxpayers' Union's North West branch
said on Monday.
"Playing the racial card when 'the country is burning' will not
improve your 'war zones' while all the people of this nation
suffer," NTU North West chairperson Carin Visser wrote in an open
letter to Shiceka.
Last week, Shiceka charged that white ratepayer associations had
created "a parallel government" and were undermining
municipalities' ability to deliver services.
"They take the money instead of paying service to municipalities
and put it in a trust account.
"That undermines ability of municipalities to deliver services."
Shiceka's office was not available on Monday to comment on the
letter.
Allegations are 'ridiculous'
"We are being blamed for creating 'parallel structures of
governance' next to completely dysfunctional structures. The
comparison is ridiculous. Do you want us to accept raw sewage as a
way of life?" asked Visser.
Ratepayers' associations had been formed because service
delivery was in a chaotic state.
They had used the money they collected to repair and maintain
essential services for the benefit of the whole community while
"mayors and municipal managers were nowhere to be seen".
Visser said the government had been told about the problems, but
had ignored them, neither acknowledging nor replying to letters and
failing to attend meetings requested by ratepayers' associations.
"We are experiencing a government with insufficient capacity and
integrity," she wrote. "We have to endure a government without
skills and competence in all the departments."
Visser said the government was not aware of the magnitude of
conflict in the country.
'A revolt is rising'
"Within the deteriorating conditions of the towns and townships
a revolt is rising which cannot be ignored."
Protests over poor service delivery were spreading, becoming
more violent and more frequent. "If the seething anger is not
contained, violent protests could become a permanent way of life in
our towns."
"Sending in the police force to control the revolt is not
solving the problem, but only creating aggression. Address the
reason for the revolt," Visser wrote, identifying fraud and
corruption as major problems.
It was not wise to threaten legal action against people who were
trying to improve their situation.
"...You will be creating a backlash from all the ordinary men
and women in the street which you will regret in the days to come,"
she warned.
'Getting what you deserve'
In a separate letter posted on the internet, its author Francois
Roux asked whether Shiceka had considered that whites' actions
might have "just a little bit to do with mismanagement of funds".
Shiceka had no problem overlooking destruction of property
during violent protests over service delivery, to make illegal
connections or because it was sub-standard.
"But heaven forbid, let just 280 white ratepayers withhold their
rates, exactly because they are unhappy about this whole situation,
then it's a huge problem."
Roux doubted that violent protests over services would ever stop
with an attitude such as Shiceka's. "... You are getting what you
deserve," he said.
Democratic Alliance co-operative governance spokesperson Willem
Doman last week labelled Shiceka's raising of the issue as "just
another example of the (African National Congress) using the race
card to deflect attention away from the real concerns of ordinary
South Africans.
"If the ANC is serious about dealing with service delivery
protests, then the best thing they could do is start to deliver
services," he said.